Celebrit-izing Animal Rights Activism?
May 6, 2015
From protesting about tortured birds, to endorsing the benefits of an all vegan diet, and
boycotting abusive animal acts, animal activists have had a steadfast view on change. They have
sought out the opportunity to change the lives of humans and benefit the lives of animals
worldwide. Creating non-for-profit organizations such as PETA, Mercy For Animals, and IDA
(In Defense of Animals), animal activists have made a true career out of saving the lives of
animals. Animal activists go out of their way to help animals who are abused and neglected.
Sarah McLachlan is a Canadian musician, singer, song writer, and an animal rights activist that
has actively campaigned for the ASPCA from as early as 2006.
In a particular commercial for the ASPCA, there are multiple panels of despondent
animals and a set of impactful title cards meant to catch at-home-viewers as McLachlan’s song
“In the Arms of the Angel” plays in the background.
Finally McLachlan appears onscreen while petting a golden retriever. She begins a
monologue and stares sadly into the eyes of her viewers and asks them to donate for a cause. The
commercial continues as she talks about how viewers will receive a photo of the animal they will
be helping. Her words aren’t as heartfelt as they should be and seem to feel as cold as the keys of
a teleprompter.
Kira Brekke, of The HuffPost Live recently wrote an article in which McLachlan
expressed her dread at watching the ASPCA commercial she started in.
“The famed singer has lent her voice to numerous commercials sponsored by the
American Society For The Prevention Of Cruelty to Animals that feature sad-looking animals
desperate for a home…” during Brekke’s interview McLachlan explained—“I change the
channel. I can’t take it… I can’t even look at it. It’s just so depressing.”
When celebrities are cast to pull on heartstrings, is it really about the animals or the
money?
Executive Director, Jon Bockman, of the Animal Charity Evaluators explained during an
email interview that celebrities are commonly used to catch the viewer’s eye.
“I think most charities are trying to do good, but that some are just more effective at
achieving their goals than others. Organizations use celebrity faces because the general public
often looks up to celebrities, so seeing a celebrity engage in a particular behavior can influence
other people’s behavior,” he said.
However, not everyone believes that the money truly is donated to fund the animal
activist organizations. There are many people who believe that the money goes to the workers or
volunteers.
Kathrine Ainsworth of The Seattle Dogs Examine, captured a picture perfect view of why
donations have diminished in recent years.
“One of the ASPCA’s and HSUS’s favored expenditures is advertising. And although it
is logical that one must spend money to make money, perhaps they get a bit carried away… A
weighty issue for critics of the ASPCA is their handling of advertising on a national level. The
ASPCA is one of the largest and most profitable ACG charities in the country, but it is located in
New York,” she wrote.
Viewers don’t often donate because they are unclear as to where their donations are
actually going.
Ainsworth explained that “There are an estimated 3,500 animal shelters in the United
States, some of which are SPCAs and some of which the public believes are HSUS-affiliated.
The perception that your local SPCA shelter is linked to the ASPCA and therefore will receive
some portion of the donations you make to the phone number shown during commercials like
Sarah McLachlan’s ad is false. At the low end, there is a growing group of critics claiming the
ASPCA uses only $11.00 of every $100.00 donated on the animals. In order to get an idea of the
most likely situation for yourself, consider these verifiable statistics regarding how many animals
the ASCPA “saved” in 2012.”
In reality, even the ASPCA isn’t true to its own word. A way to change this would really
be to allow donators to apply for the adoption of abandoned and stray animals.
Professor Broderick
Capstone
3/26/15